Construction is among the most dangerous work in Florida, and injured workers are usually told the same thing on day one: workers compensation is your only option. That is frequently wrong. Compensation covers your employer. It does not cover everyone else on a busy site, and on most projects there are many other companies present.
Workers Compensation and the Third-Party Claim
Florida workers compensation is generally the exclusive remedy against your own employer. It pays medical care and a portion of lost wages without requiring proof of fault, and in exchange it limits what can be recovered from the employer. Critically, it does not compensate for pain and suffering.
A third-party claim is a separate civil action against a party other than your employer whose negligence contributed to the injury. It can be pursued alongside a compensation claim, and it does allow recovery for pain and suffering and for the full measure of lost earning capacity.
Who the Third Party Usually Is
- A general contractor responsible for overall site safety and coordination, subject to the statutory immunity rules discussed below
- Another subcontractor whose work created the hazard, such as an uncovered floor opening or an unguarded excavation
- The property owner, particularly where the owner retained control over the work or the condition of the premises
- Equipment manufacturers and lessors, where a machine, lift, or tool was defective or improperly maintained
- Scaffolding suppliers and erectors
- Crane operators and rigging contractors
- Delivery and trucking companies operating on site
- Engineers and architects, in circumstances involving design or specification failures
The Statutory Employer Rule
An important qualification applies to claims against general contractors. Florida’s workers compensation scheme extends immunity in defined circumstances to contractors who secure compensation coverage for the employees of their subcontractors, treating them as statutory employers for that purpose.
The rule has limits, including exceptions where conduct goes beyond ordinary negligence. Whether it applies to a particular defendant is a fact-specific analysis that depends on the contractual structure of the project and on who secured coverage for whom, which is exactly the kind of question that needs answering early rather than assumed.
Subcontractors on the same project can share in that protection too. In many cases Florida shields a subcontractor from a suit by another subcontractor’s injured employee, as long as compensation coverage was in place and the subcontractor’s own gross negligence was not the major contributing cause of the injury. That makes the coverage paperwork and the subcontract chain as important as the accident itself, and it is why companies outside that structure, such as equipment lessors, manufacturers, delivery companies and engineers, often carry the third-party claim.
How Workers Are Seriously Hurt
The recurring categories on Florida sites are falls from height, including from roofs, scaffolds, ladders, and through unprotected floor and skylight openings; being struck by falling materials, tools, or swinging loads; caught-in and caught-between injuries involving machinery, vehicles, and collapsing trench walls; and electrocution from contact with overhead power lines, energised circuits, and failures of lockout and tagout procedure.
Florida adds heat illness to that list. Working outdoors through a Florida summer produces genuine and sometimes fatal heat injury, and inadequate provision of water, shade, and rest is a recurring failure.
Scaffold, Ladder and Roof Falls
Falls are the leading cause of death in construction, and the federal construction standards draw the line clearly: fall protection is generally required at six feet above a lower level, and on scaffolds at ten feet. Guardrails, personal fall arrest systems, secured covers over floor holes and properly built scaffolds are the standard tools. In a scaffold case, therefore, we look at who erected the scaffold, whether it was fully planked and braced, and whether a competent person inspected it before the shift as the rules require. In a roofing case, by contrast, the first questions are whether anchors and harnesses were supplied at all and whether anyone made sure they were used.
Crane, Hoist and Struck-By Accidents
Struck-by injuries come from swinging and dropped loads, falling tools and materials, and equipment backing over workers on the ground. Crane work adds its own chain of responsibility, because the crane owner or lessor, the operator, the rigger and signal person, and the contractor that planned the lift can each carry part of it. Federal construction rules also require trained and certified operators and qualified riggers for crane work. Since the crane is often owned and run by a company other than the injured worker’s employer, crane cases are among the clearest third-party claims on a construction site.
OSHA Rules, Inspections and Citations
Federal workplace safety regulations, administered by OSHA, govern fall protection, scaffolding, excavation and trenching, ladder use, electrical safety, cranes, and machine guarding. When a worker dies, the employer must report it to OSHA within eight hours, and an in-patient hospitalization, an amputation or the loss of an eye within 24 hours. Those reports commonly lead to an inspection, which produces photographs, interview notes, measurements and, where violations are found, citations against one or more of the companies on site.
A citation issued after an incident does not by itself decide a civil claim, but the underlying standards are strong evidence of what reasonable care required, and the investigation file frequently contains statements and findings that would otherwise be difficult to obtain. The file can usually be requested once OSHA closes its case. Because an inspection may cite a general contractor or another subcontractor rather than your employer, we read it for every company it names.
Undocumented Workers
Immigration status, by itself, does not prevent an injured worker from bringing a claim against a responsible third party in Florida, although a workers compensation claim can raise separate questions. Fear of raising status is one of the main reasons serious injuries go uncompensated on construction sites, so anyone in that position should get confidential advice about their specific circumstances rather than assume nothing can be done.
Para información en español, consulte nuestra página de abogado de accidentes de construcción en Florida.
Damages and the Compensation Lien
A third-party claim may include past and future medical care beyond what compensation pays, full lost income and diminished earning capacity, pain and suffering, disfigurement, and wrongful death damages. Where compensation benefits have been paid, the carrier will typically assert a lien against any third-party recovery, and how that lien is resolved materially affects the net outcome for the worker.
What to Do After a Construction Injury
- Report the injury to your employer in writing, and seek medical care immediately
- Photograph the site, the equipment, and the hazard before it is cleared or corrected
- Write down every company present on the site that day, not just your own employer
- Identify witnesses, including workers employed by other companies
- Preserve any defective tool or equipment, and do not let it be returned or repaired
- Do not give a recorded statement to any insurer other than as your compensation claim requires
- Get advice about a possible third-party claim, since compensation alone rarely covers a serious injury
Construction Accident Lawyers Across Florida
The third-party rules above apply on every Florida site. What changes with the location, however, is the kind of project, the companies on it and the courthouse that hears the case. We handle construction injury cases statewide, so these areas are examples rather than a limit.
Tampa. High-rise and mixed-use towers downtown and in the Water Street district, along with port and road work, put many trades on the same site. Hillsborough County cases are filed in the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, and our Tampa office also meets clients by appointment.
Orlando. Resort, hotel and attraction projects, together with steady road and residential building, keep Orange County sites crowded with subcontractors. When one of those cases is filed, it goes to the Ninth Judicial Circuit; see our Orlando page.
Miami. Condominium towers bring cranes, hoists and tall scaffolds onto tight urban sites, so falls and struck-by injuries are a particular concern. Miami-Dade cases are heard in the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, as our Miami page explains.
Jacksonville. Port, warehouse and road projects across Duval County, by contrast, bring heavy equipment and trucking onto the site, and those cases go to the Fourth Judicial Circuit; see our Jacksonville page.
Lakeland and Polk County. Warehouses and distribution centers along the I-4 corridor, as well as new residential subdivisions, mean roofing, steel and heavy-equipment work across the county. Polk County cases, meanwhile, are filed in the Tenth Judicial Circuit, as our Lakeland page explains.
Fort Myers and Cape Coral. Rebuilding since Hurricane Ian, along with steady new home and commercial construction, keeps roofing, framing, seawall and heavy-equipment crews busy across Lee County. Those cases are filed in the Twentieth Judicial Circuit; see our Fort Myers and Cape Coral pages.
How Alegra Law Handles Construction Cases
We map the contractual structure of the project to identify every entity that was present and every party that owed a duty, then evaluate which are genuinely shielded by compensation immunity and which are not. We preserve equipment and site evidence quickly, obtain the safety investigation file, and coordinate the third-party claim with the compensation claim, including lien resolution. There is no attorney’s fee unless we recover, and clients may remain responsible for costs as described in the written fee agreement.
What a Florida Construction Accident Lawyer Untangles
A single site can involve a general contractor, several subcontractors, an equipment supplier, a staffing agency and the property owner, each insured separately. A Florida construction accident lawyer establishes who controlled the hazard, which is often not the injured worker’s own employer. That is the first question a construction injury attorney asks after a fall, a trench collapse or an electrocution.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is workers compensation really my only option?
Frequently not. Compensation is generally the exclusive remedy against your own employer, but a third-party claim may lie against another company whose negligence contributed, such as another subcontractor, a property owner, an equipment lessor, or a manufacturer. That claim does allow recovery for pain and suffering.
Can I sue the general contractor?
Sometimes, but Florida extends immunity in defined circumstances to contractors who secure compensation coverage for a subcontractor's employees, treating them as statutory employers. Whether it applies depends on the contractual structure of the project and who secured coverage for whom, which needs analysing rather than assuming.
Does an OSHA citation win my case?
Not by itself, but it helps. The underlying safety standards are strong evidence of what reasonable care required, and the investigation file often contains statements and findings that would otherwise be difficult to obtain.
I am undocumented. Can I still bring a claim?
Immigration status, by itself, does not prevent an injury claim against a responsible third party in Florida, although a workers compensation claim can raise separate questions. Fear of raising status is one of the main reasons serious construction injuries go uncompensated, so anyone in that position should get confidential advice about their own circumstances.
What happens to the workers compensation benefits I already received?
The compensation carrier will typically assert a lien against any third-party recovery to recoup what it paid. How that lien is negotiated and resolved materially affects what you actually keep, and it should be handled as part of the case rather than at the end.
What does it cost to hire Alegra Law for a construction injury claim?
Nothing upfront. We work on contingency, and if there is no recovery you owe no attorney’s fee. Clients may remain responsible for costs and expenses as described in the written fee agreement, and all fee terms are provided in writing before you sign.